Just looking at the cast roster, I'm thinking that people would be more like, "But they're so freaking crazy...it's weird :C" before they even noticed the magic...

(Just read that Butters/Kincaid fic down yonder and it has put some strange yet adorable images into my brain. Of all the ships I never thought would even float, let alone sail. Jeez.)

Go for it, doll. I wave my pompoms in your honor.